next up previous
Next: Sub-Constituent Focus Up: Focusing F-structure Heads Previous: Yes-no Questions

``Contrastive'' Focus

Contrastive focus picks out one element as prominent new information (Choi 1996 and references therein). In Russian contrastive focus is encoded intonationally, not via the phrase structure (Junghanns and Zybatov 1995). That is, there is no one phrase structure position associated with contrastive focus, although contrastively focused arguments and adjuncts tend to occur immediately before the verb (King 1995). In (9) the verb procitala `read' is contrastively focused. The heavy stress on the verb, indicating its focus status, is indicated by small caps.

(9)

tabular388

Contrastive focus assignment can be captured by annotating the c-structure node containing the focused material and assigning the appropriate stress. The question is what the appropriate annotation should be. Using tex2html_wrap_inline527 tex2html_wrap_inline549 ( tex2html_wrap_inline525 FOC) will result in too wide a scope because it will focus the entire f-structure, as with the li yes-no questions, and will also create the same circularity found with these.gif The other alternative is to use ( tex2html_wrap_inline527 PRED) tex2html_wrap_inline549 ( tex2html_wrap_inline525 FOC). This gives rise to the f-structure in (10).

(10)

avm124

The problem is that by focusing the head `read;SPMlt;SUBJ,OBJ;SPMgt;' not only is the core meaning of the PRED focused, but so are its arguments, the subject `she' and the object `book'. However, the interpretation of contrastive focus on the verb excludes focus of any material other than the verb itself. This is particularly problematic since the arguments have other discourse functions which clash with the assigned focus role.



Tracy Holloway King
Sat Jul 26 11:26:37 PDT 1997